İçeriğe atla

Vikipedi:Botlar/Başvurular/King Willan Bot

Bağlantı ekle
Vikipedi, özgür ansiklopedi
Aşağıdaki bot başvurusunun arşivlenmiş tartışmasıdır. Lütfen üzerinde değişiklik yapmayınız. Bu sayfaya herhangi bir ek değişiklik yapılmamalıdır.

Bot başvurusu sonucunda kullanıcıya bot statüsü verilmemesine karar verilmiştir.

User:King Willan Bot

[kaynağı değiştir]

Destek Destek

[kaynağı değiştir]

Karşı Karşı

[kaynağı değiştir]
  1. Karşı Karşı
    Hello !
    Some bot owners here might already know me, I am NicDumZ, an experienced French bot owner running DumZiBoT on fr: (see stats), on en:, and on de:.
    After some hesitations on whether I should do this or not, I go on every wiki where this user has requested a flag to comment his request : One could not deny that King Willan is showing good willingness, seems very honest and motivated, and that he could be trusted; Still, on fr:, his home wiki, we have denied his bot flag request. Upon discussion, it turns out that King Willan is a bit young and that he is not experienced at all in interwikis and bot handling :
    • When asked about some dubious edits his bot made (e.g. [1] and [2]), he answered (rough translation) Well, the program asked me what to do; I checked the first foreign interwiki, then clicked on the fr: interwiki from the foreign page; Since it didn't bring me back to my originating page, I removed the interwikis. I think that this is showing some serious misunderstanding of the interwiki system, proving that this user is not qualified enough in interwiki handling.
    • We explained him that he was mistaken on these particular edits, and why : he answered back that his pywikipedia copy was out of date (he downloaded a 08/2007 snapshot from sourceforge), and that surely the framework had misleaded him and that it wasn't his fault. :s
    • He asked on several places technical questions on pywikipedia, proving that he does not know how this framework works, and probably that he does not understand python :
    • I strongly believe that he his not able to speak or understand English enough to communicate with other projects, to explain what he did, or simply to understand their policies:
      • The technical questions he asked have easy answers in English in the documentation of the framework.
      • When I went on his de: and en: requests to comment them, he asked me to translate in French what I wrote (diff: [3])
      • Moreover, this diff [4], where he states "The bad version no take this fonction. My version take now this fonction" is quite... significant. :(
    We're trying to see what can be done, on fr:, to teach him to use his tools properly, but for all the reasons stated above, I consider that, as of now, letting him have a botflag on so many projects at once would be very, very treacherous.
    I will not be monitoring this page; Please, let me now on my French talk page if you have any questions, remarks, or if any further discussion goes on here.
    Thanks a lot.
    NicDumZ ~ 14:36, 5 Şubat 2008 (UTC)
  1. Karşı Karşı NicDumZ'nin söylediklerine atfen.--Machiavelli' msj 12:33, 13 Şubat 2008 (UTC)
  2. Karşı Karşı Yukarıdaki yorumlardan kullanıcının bot yazacak yeterlilikte olmadığı sonucuna vardığım için oyumu değiştiriyorum.--Eldarionileti 23:59, 13 Şubat 2008 (UTC)
  3. Karşı Karşı - Yukarıdaki nota dayanarak...--Math34 10:44, 14 Şubat 2008 (UTC)

Tarafsız Tarafsız

[kaynağı değiştir]

Tartışma Tartışma

[kaynağı değiştir]

Sonuç Sonuç

[kaynağı değiştir]
Yukarıdaki bot başvurusunun arşivlenmiş tartışmasıdır. Lütfen üzerinde değişiklik yapmayınız. Bu sayfaya herhangi bir ek değişiklik yapılmamalıdır.



"https://tr.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Vikipedi:Botlar/Başvurular/King_Willan_Bot&oldid=20022052" sayfasından alınmıştır